|
SNAKE OIL, MOUSETRAPS & HOMING PIGEONS
A conclusion to the day by Mike
Evans, founder and managing director of Cambashi Ltd
CBS.017
Issue 1 10/05/98
Mike Evans gave a highly entertaining
summary of the day, and an astute vision of the current situation
in the market for IT in industry. "Industrial computer technology
hits the market in waves," he said. "From computing based on data
centres in the 1960s, we have seen departmental computing give way
to desktop technology."
Mr Evans believes that the
market is currently in a transitional period between desktop and
network-centred computing. This coincides with a period where users
are becoming far more sophisticated - often their knowledge in many
areas is as great as or greater than that of vendors' sales staff.
Snakeoil - smooth talk that assumes that the sales rep has the superior
knowledge - simply will not do any more. There is also an increasing
demand for best-of-breed applications in preference for seamless
integration, which can compromise functionality.
Year 2000 issues and the introduction
of the Euro present a double whammy. They are currently taking up
about 10% of companies' IT budgets.
But what will happen to this money
in future? ERP is the acronym on everyone's lips, but new applications
are likely to become equally critical. In future, departmental managers
will have to justify all capital investments. Competition will not
just be from alternative IT products, but from elsewhere - buildings,
new company cars, plant and machinery will all vie for a share of
the corporate cake. He warned that too much sales literature is
entirely product oriented, claiming that the products were "better"
than other similar products. The real issues are implementation
and the sustainability of the solution. Vendors must be prepared
with the right marketing message to confront this new challenge:
"laser" or "paintball" marketing must be confined to the past. The
successful vendor will in future be the "homing pigeon", identifying
customers' unique requirements and creating a specific marketing
message in response to these. "It may be best in future to emphasise
changes in business practices and the role of the supplier as a
facilitator, working in partnership with the customer to create
and maintain an overall IT environment that improves the performance
of the business," he said.
"Users," he continued, "have
three main options for IT implementation: change management through
consultants and systems integrators; productivity improvements through
VARS; or personal productivity through cheap, over-the-counter purchases."
He likened systems integrators
to cruise ships: sedate and expensive (and they have good lunches).
There are not many good systems integrators, but their great strength
is in their ability to supply services beyond the products, and
at ensuring the longevity of systems.
On the other hand, there are something
like 3000 VARs in Europe - but many of these are little more than
product shippers. Although they are supposed to add value to the
products they sell, many of them simply sell at discounted prices,
and add no value whatsoever. The best VARS supply training and service
at minimum.
Anyone who buys cheap does not
have a leg to stand on if product performance does not meet expectations.
Mr Evans suggested that OEMs should protect themselves by establishing
brand values for new and emerging applications.
The North American market is already
changing fast, and Europe will soon follow. Vendors need to be prepared
with new marketing messages. They need to be aware of issues such
as who has the right sales and marketing skills, whether it is possible
to retrain, what the metrics are for the new business model, and
what will drive users' buying decisions.
And where is technology taking
us? ERP and PDM are converging fast - informed opinion has it that
SAP will buy a CAD company before long. Gartner Group talks about
the emergence of "PDMII", but Cambashi believes that this view is
a compromise resulting from an internal power struggle.
Mr Evans maintains that users want
vendors to provide products that improve business models and processes.
Cambashi's money is on ORP, and Mike Evans' advice to vendors is
"look at how the market is changing, who the future decision makers
will be and how to reach them. Then plan for an innovative sales
pigeon."
back to top
|